Bette Davis’ Emotional Victory

dark victory

“I’ve never taken orders from anyone. As long as I live, I’ll never take orders from anyone. I’m young and strong and nothing can touch me.”

Dark Victory (1939) is a prime example of the power of a Bette Davis performance. Playing the part of terminally-ill heiress Judith Traherne, Davis commands full attention when onscreen, capable of breaking even the most apathetic audience. Full of youth and beauty herself, Davis passionately portrays this character with a tragic fate.

dark victory

The plot of the film centers around a lovely, vivacious young woman who is diagnosed with an incurable brain tumor. At first, her handsome doctor, Frederick Steele (played by George Brent), attempts to conceal the truth of her condition in order to allow her as much happiness as she can gather during her last months. The two fall in love as they await the inevitable.

dark victory

The main character Judith, once aware of her fate, understandably undergoes a wide range of emotions. Upon the discovery, she first becomes enraged that her fiance/doctor, with the help of her best friend Ann (Geraldine Fitzgerald), has hidden the truth of her condition. Believing that he is only marrying her out of pity, she turns to the company of many other men (including a young Ronald Reagan) as a distraction from her unavoidable end. But an encounter with no-nonsense Michael (Humphrey Bogart), one of the grooms who handles her racehorses, leads Judith to a moment of self-realization in which she finds the inner strength and peace needed to face her fate.

"Of the men I didn't marry, the dearest was George Brent."

“Of the men I didn’t marry, the dearest was George Brent.”

During the filming of Dark Victory, Davis was suffering her own personal tragedy; she was going through a divorce from her first husband, “Ham” Nelson, who was leaving her. Like her character in Dark Victory, Davis also reportedly had a string of lovers following her divorce. In fact, the emotional progression of her character in the film is nearly parallel to her own off-screen reality. Davis seems quite blissful toward the end scenes of the film as her character learns to accept her fate; perhaps this is because she was in the throes of love, embroiled in a new romance with her (frequent) leading man, George Brent. Though Brent proposed, Davis eventually left him a year later to marry Arthur Farnsworth.

dark victory

Early in the shooting for the film, Davis reportedly asked to be replaced as the lead role, fearing that in the midst of her personal emotional upheaval, she could not effectively play the doomed Judith. Thankfully, her request was ignored, and she went on to give a tremendous performance, one that scored her the third of ten Academy Award nominations for Best Actress. Just imagine what a tragedy it would have been for this role not to have been played by Davis, whose own emotional experiences during this period of her life must surely have assisted her in performing so brilliantly.


bette davis suts blogathon bannerThis post is an entry in the ongoing “Summer Under the Stars Blogathon” hosted by Sittin’ on a Backyard Fence and ScribeHard on Film. Make sure to check out the other entries that have been dedicated to the inimitable Bette Davis today.

7 thoughts on “Bette Davis’ Emotional Victory

  1. Thank you for such an affectionate post about a movie that I, too, love. I enjoy Davis’ friendship with Geraldine Fitzgerald. That solid, loyal relationship helps keep us rooting for Judith, even when, toward the beginning, she isn’t all that sympathetic

  2. Hey, I’m watching this movie now, as I’m reading your blog. Poor Bette has just read her file and discovered the “prognosis negative”.

    I can’t imagine anyone other that Bette in this role. She really carries this film.



    Dark Victory is so delicious and soapy and marvelous. And no one has looked better on their deathbed in the history of ever, than Ms. Bette Davis.

    Thanks for a great contribution to the blogathon and I’m so sorry it has taken me a bit to get over here.

  4. I love “Dark Victory” so much and still do so after many years since I’ve seen this movie for the first time. It’s been told that Judith Traherne was Bette Davis’ favorite role.

    I never understood why she and George Brent never tried to live permanently together. In my opinion they seem to be the perfect couple and their marriage couldn’t be more disastrous than her four and his five tries which ended in divorce. But maybe it was wiser for them to stay lifelong friends than to become embittered ex-spouses.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s